
Earning More, Owing More: Why Debt Review Is Not a Low-Income Product
September 14, 2026
Can You Leave Debt Review While You Still Have a Home Loan?
October 1, 2026By Adv Ancil van Heerden DCASA NEC member
Informed Consent, Lawful Fees, Court Referrals, Consumer Funds and Debt Review Removal Services
The Debt Counsellors Association of South Africa (DCASA) has issued an Industry Directive and Compliance Alert following the National Consumer Tribunal judgment in National Credit Regulator v Bongolethu Gedeza, NCT/444880/2026/137(1), delivered on 15 September 2026.
The judgment deals with a number of important compliance concerns within the debt counselling industry, including consumers being placed under debt review without informed consent, misleading marketing, unlawful or excessive fees, legal fees where matters were not referred, improper handling of consumer funds, debt review “removal” services, inadequate records and the use of undisclosed entities or trading names.
DCASA has issued the directive to assist debt counsellors in reviewing their own practices and taking corrective action where required. It is intended as practical industry guidance and does not replace the National Credit Act, regulations, conditions of registration, binding court or Tribunal decisions or directives issued by the National Credit Regulator.
Why this judgment matters
The Gedeza matter proceeded on a default basis, with the respondent neither filing an answering affidavit nor appearing at the hearing. The NCR relied on more than 200 complaints and examined a sample of 20 consumer files. The Tribunal found that the evidence demonstrated repeated conduct and an identifiable modus operandi rather than isolated administrative errors.
The Tribunal ultimately declared the respondent’s conduct prohibited, cancelled the respondent’s registration as a debt counsellor, ordered an independent audit and surrender of consumer files, required certain refunds and corrective action, and imposed an administrative fine of R1 million.
For the broader industry, the judgment provides an important reminder that compliance is not simply about having the correct forms on file. Debt counsellors must be able to demonstrate that consumers gave informed consent, that services were actually performed, that matters were progressed diligently and that every material action can be supported by a reliable audit trail.
DCASA’s 10 non-negotiable compliance principles
Following its review of the judgment, DCASA has identified ten principles which members are directed to incorporate into their practices:
- No consumer may be placed under debt review without informed and voluntary consent.
- No debt counsellor may misrepresent the nature or consequences of debt review.
- No unauthorised, excessive or invented fee may be charged.
- No legal fee may be retained without corresponding legal work.
- No consumer funds may be collected or distributed contrary to Regulation 11.
- No debt review removal service may be promised where removal is not legally possible.
- Every matter requiring referral must be dealt with diligently.
- Every consumer file must contain a complete and reliable audit trail.
- Every trading name and material business change must be disclosed to the NCR.
- Every debt counsellor must cooperate with lawful regulatory monitoring and enforcement.
These principles should be read together with the full DCASA directive and the applicable provisions of the National Credit Act and regulations.
Informed consent must come first
One of the strongest messages arising from the judgment is that an enquiry must not automatically be treated as an application for debt review.
A consumer must knowingly and voluntarily apply for debt review in accordance with section 86(1) and Regulation 24. Debt review should not be marketed merely as an interest-rate reduction or instalment-reduction service, and consumers should not be led to believe that the process has no effect on their credit profile.
Before an application is processed, consumers should understand the nature of debt review, the restrictions on obtaining further credit, the assessment process, applicable fees, their payment obligations and the limited circumstances in which a debt review status can lawfully be removed.
Importantly, debt counsellors must also be able to prove that this explanation and consent occurred.
Marketing and lead generation remain the debt counsellor’s responsibility
Debt counsellors cannot outsource regulatory responsibility to a marketing company, call centre, lead generator, agent or employee.
Marketing conducted in the name of a debt counsellor must not conceal the fact that a consumer is applying for debt review, promise guaranteed reductions, imply government or NCR affiliation without lawful authority, or promise that a court order can simply be cancelled or rescinded.
This means debt counsellors should review not only their own websites and advertisements, but also scripts, social-media campaigns, lead-generation funnels and third-party marketing arrangements.
Fees must correspond with actual services
The directive also reinforces that fees must fall within the applicable framework and must correspond with services actually rendered.
Debt counsellors may not invent additional fee categories, retain fees for work that was never performed, retain legal fees where there was no corresponding legal work, or charge for a service that cannot lawfully be delivered. Where an improper fee has been charged or retained, the directive states that it should be identified and refunded without delay.
Similarly, where legal fees are charged, they must relate to identifiable legal services and be supported by proof that the work was actually performed. A consumer’s matter cannot simply remain unfiled while legal fees continue to be retained.
Consumer funds must be processed lawfully
Regulation 11 prohibits a debt counsellor from collecting or distributing debt review payments on behalf of consumers.
Funds intended for distribution to credit providers must therefore be handled through a registered Payment Distribution Agent (PDA). Every payment should be identifiable, properly authorised, accurately recorded and capable of reconciliation.
The DCASA directive also records an important factual correction regarding the Tribunal judgment: DC Partner (Pty) Ltd is a registered PDA under NCRPDA2. Accordingly, the relevant compliance question is whether payments were processed through the registered PDA system or paid directly into accounts controlled by the respondent or associated entities.
Debt review “removal” is not a general cancellation service
DCASA has consistently cautioned consumers and industry participants against portraying debt review removal as a simple administrative cancellation process.
The directive confirms that where a debt-rearrangement court order has been granted, the debt review cannot simply be withdrawn by the debt counsellor. A Form 17.7 cannot terminate the debt review, nor can a consumer automatically be promised removal simply because their financial circumstances have improved.
Debt counsellors must therefore ensure that staff, consumers and marketing partners understand the legal distinction between rejection, transfer, clearance and lawful post-order processes.
This is also particularly important for consumers. Be extremely cautious of any business promising to “remove your debt review flag” without first establishing your legal status and the circumstances of your matter.
Complete consumer files are essential
A compliant debt counselling file must tell the complete story of the consumer’s matter.
This includes proof of the application and informed consent, supporting affordability documentation, Forms 17.1 and 17.2, certificates of balance, the assessment, restructuring proposal, court or Tribunal referral, resulting orders, PDA records and relevant correspondence.
A debt counsellor should be able to demonstrate, from the file itself, what happened, when it happened, who authorised it and what evidence supports the action taken.
Immediate compliance review recommended
DCASA recommends that debt counsellors now conduct an internal review of their practices, particularly in relation to:
- consumer consent and proof thereof;
- completeness of consumer files and audit trails;
- fees and possible refunds;
- outstanding legal referrals;
- legal work for which fees have already been collected;
- PDA processing and payment reconciliations;
- advertisements, scripts, call centres and lead providers;
- debt review cancellation or removal services; and
- trading names, addresses and related entities disclosed to the NCR.
Any irregularity identified should be addressed promptly, and where consumers have been improperly charged, refunds should be calculated, documented and processed.
Protecting consumers and protecting the integrity of debt counselling
The Gedeza judgment should not be viewed simply as enforcement against one individual debt counsellor.
It is an important reminder to the entire industry that debt counselling is a regulated professional service carrying significant responsibilities toward financially vulnerable consumers.
DCASA supports firm action against practices that undermine consumer confidence or the integrity of the statutory debt review process. At the same time, the judgment provides responsible debt counsellors with a valuable opportunity to review their systems, strengthen their documentation and ensure that their businesses remain aligned with the NCA, regulations and applicable legal authority.
Consumers should always ensure that they are dealing with a registered debt counsellor, understand what they are signing before entering debt review and ensure that debt review payments are made through a registered PDA.
The full DCASA Industry Directive and Compliance Alert: NCR v Bongolethu Gedeza should be read by all debt counsellors and relevant staff. It was published by DCASA on 23 September 2026.
Issued by the Debt Counsellors Association of South Africa (DCASA)



