
DCASA Engages with the NCR Complaints Department: What Debt Counsellors Need to Know
September 4, 2026
Earning More, Owing More: Why Debt Review Is Not a Low-Income Product
September 14, 2026Perhaps it is that time of year — when everyone is running on fumes, meetings have become a blur, and every effort to reach industry consensus starts to feel a little harder.
But there is one issue that keeps coming back.
DCRS.
For years, debt counsellors and DCASA members have been involved in discussions, meetings, working groups and engagements around the Debt Counselling Restructuring Standard (DCRS).
We sit around the table.
We debate.
We disagree.
We negotiate.
We compromise.
And ultimately, we reach a position that the industry can work towards.
There is an agreed objective: promote the use of DCRS as a restructuring mechanism that can assist consumers and create greater consistency in debt review proposals.
Yet then the emails start.
A debt counsellor submits a DCRS proposal.
A creditor does not accept it.
An interest-rate concession is not accepted.
A repayment proposal is rejected.
The debt counsellor goes back to the drawing board.
And suddenly, we are asking the same questions we thought we had already addressed around the meeting table.
The uncomfortable question: who is actually bound by the guidelines?
This is where the frustration begins.
Over the years, we have seen debt counsellors face compliance concerns, interventions and even threats of regulatory action relating to their adherence to guidelines and processes issued by the NCR.
The argument is often that certain guidelines form part of a debt counsellor’s conditions of registration and therefore become binding on that debt counsellor.
Fair enough.
If a registered debt counsellor is required to comply with the regulatory framework governing the industry, then compliance must be taken seriously.
But that brings us to an uncomfortable question:
Where is the same consistency when it comes to the other side of the transaction?
If the industry has spent years negotiating a restructuring framework designed to facilitate debt review, why are we still seeing debt counsellors being told that particular DCRS proposals will not be accepted?
And if creditors are entitled to make their own decisions regarding their internal protocols and acceptance criteria, then perhaps we need to be honest about what “industry guidelines” actually mean in practice.
We cannot have a one-sided system of compliance
This is not an argument that creditors should simply accept every proposal submitted by a debt counsellor.
Nor is it an argument that creditors should surrender their legitimate commercial or legal rights.
And importantly, an interest-rate concession is not automatically a statutory consumer right.
Where creditors voluntarily agree to reduce interest rates or provide other concessions, the industry should recognise that these concessions are valuable.
They can make a substantial difference to the consumer.
A reduced interest rate can mean the consumer exits debt review considerably sooner.
It can reduce the total cost of the debt.
It can improve the sustainability of the repayment arrangement.
And ultimately, it can assist the consumer in returning to the formal credit market sooner.
These concessions are appreciated.
But appreciation of a concession does not remove the need to ask whether the overall system is being applied consistently.
So why did we have all those meetings?
This is perhaps the part that is becoming increasingly difficult for debt counsellors to understand.
If DCRS is something the industry wants to promote, why have we spent countless hours in meetings trying to reach consensus around it?
Why have debt counsellors been encouraged to utilise it?
Why have regulatory expectations been placed on debt counsellors around industry processes?
Why continue to spend hours trying to improve a system if, at the implementation stage, individual creditors can simply decide not to participate in particular circumstances?
Perhaps there is a perfectly legitimate answer.
If so, the industry needs to hear it.
Because from the debt counsellor’s perspective, the process can become incredibly frustrating.
A debt counsellor attends the meetings.
The debt counsellor implements what was agreed.
The debt counsellor submits the proposal.
And then the proposal is rejected.
The consumer is the one sitting in the middle.
And then there is the issue of “internal protocols”
Another recurring concern is the position that regulatory authorities cannot prescribe to creditors what their internal protocols should be when assessing or accepting debt review proposals.
Again, there may be sound legal reasoning behind that position.
Credit providers are separate businesses.
They have their own systems, policies and risk frameworks.
But it creates an obvious question:
If internal protocols can override or prevent practical implementation of an industry restructuring framework, what exactly are we asking debt counsellors to comply with?
We cannot continually tell one side:
“You must comply with the guideline.”
while effectively telling the other:
“The creditor may decide whether or not its internal processes accommodate it.”
At some point, the industry has to confront that imbalance.
Non-compliance cannot become a one-way street.
Are certain consumers being treated differently?
There is another issue that debt counsellors are increasingly discussing.
We are hearing concerns about whether certain types of DCRS proposals are more likely to be rejected than others.
One question being raised relates to higher-income consumers.
Are consumers with higher incomes increasingly being viewed as not being genuinely over-indebted?
Are their applications being scrutinised differently?
Are creditors less willing to accept restructuring proposals where the consumer has a higher income?
And, perhaps most importantly:
Are we underestimating the financial pressure experienced by higher-income households?
Over-indebtedness is not determined simply by looking at a person’s salary.
A higher income can come with significantly higher financial commitments.
Housing costs, school fees, vehicle finance, insurance, medical expenses, family responsibilities and other contractual obligations can place substantial pressure on a household.
A person can earn what appears to be a good income and still experience genuine financial distress.
We therefore need to be very careful about creating an assumption that:
“Higher income = cannot be over-indebted.”
The realities of household finances are considerably more complicated than that.
Is there a pattern?
This is where we need data rather than assumptions.
Are particular DCRS proposals being rejected more frequently?
Are particular categories of consumers being affected?
Are higher-income consumers experiencing greater rejection rates?
Are interest-rate concessions being rejected more frequently?
Are creditors applying materially different approaches?
And, perhaps most importantly:
Why?
These are not questions that should be answered through WhatsApp groups, frustrated emails or hallway conversations after meetings.
We need industry data.
We need transparency.
And we need honest engagement.
No, interest-rate concessions are not a right
Let’s also be very clear on this point.
DCASA is not suggesting that a consumer has an automatic legal entitlement to an interest-rate reduction simply because they enter debt review.
A concession is a concession.
Where a creditor voluntarily agrees to reduce the interest rate, that concession should be recognised for what it is — an important mechanism that can assist the consumer and improve the outcome of the debt review.
But there is a broader industry question.
If concessions are voluntarily offered as part of an established restructuring approach, and if the industry has spent years encouraging the use of that approach, how do we ensure that the process is applied consistently and transparently?
That is the conversation we should be having.
Because the consumer is ultimately the one paying the price
Every rejection has a practical consequence.
The debt counsellor must reconsider the proposal.
The repayment period may increase.
The consumer may pay more interest.
The debt review may take longer.
The consumer remains outside the credit market for longer.
And the possibility of successful rehabilitation moves further into the future.
The purpose of debt review should ultimately be to help a financially distressed consumer pay their debts in a structured and sustainable manner and eventually return to financial normality.
If the system becomes so fragmented that every creditor applies a completely different practical approach, the consumer’s outcome can become dependent on who their creditors happen to be.
That cannot be the long-term objective.
So where does that leave us?
Perhaps the answer is not another meeting.
Perhaps it is not another guideline.
Perhaps it is simply greater transparency.
If a DCRS proposal is rejected, why?
If a concession is not available, why?
If a particular category of consumer is being treated differently, why?
If creditors have internal protocols that prevent participation, what are those protocols and how do they interact with the industry’s agreed restructuring framework?
And if the existing regulatory framework genuinely cannot compel a creditor to participate, then perhaps we need to stop pretending that the playing field is level.
Let’s call it what it is and have the legislative conversation that follows.
DCASA wants to hear from debt counsellors
This is not about attacking creditors.
It is not about saying every DCRS proposal must be accepted.
It is not about suggesting that interest-rate concessions are a consumer right.
It is about understanding what is actually happening on the ground.
So, debt counsellors:
What are you seeing?
Are creditors rejecting DCRS proposals?
Are interest-rate concessions being rejected?
Are certain consumer profiles more likely to be rejected?
Are higher-income consumers experiencing different treatment?
What reasons are you being given?
And what impact is this having on your consumers?
Scroll down and Drop your experiences in the comments.
The more we understand what is happening across the industry, the better equipped we are to have meaningful discussions with the relevant stakeholders.
Because after years of meetings, negotiations and attempts to find common ground, perhaps the real question is no longer:
“Can we agree on DCRS?”
Perhaps the question is:
“How do we ensure that what we agree on actually works in practice?”



